Friday, October 01, 2010

Washington Dealt Out

Washington Dealt OutYou probably heard that as of yesterday, PokerStars is now prohibiting players in the state of Washington from playing for real money at the site.

To be specific, you cannot play at Stars if you are currently a resident of Washington, nor can you play on the site if you are visiting Washington. In fact, current residents can’t even go outside of the state and play either, as their accounts will remain blocked from real money play as long as they have Washington addresses.

The news came quite abruptly -- without any real forewarning -- prompted, it appears, by the Washington state Supreme Court’s recent ruling upholding the state’s law against online gambling. That ruling came a little over a week ago. The law had been challenged as violating a federal commerce clause regarding interstate business, but it looks like the state’s Supreme Court wasn’t swayed by that argument, and thus decided not to fiddle with the state legislature’s earlier decision to make online gambling illegal (back in 2006, I think).

While Washington-based players scramble to figure out what to do next, many are speculating both about why PokerStars decided to pull the plug once and for all on Washington, as well as what might happen next.

Some are suggesting that PokerStars’ decision to block Washington customers -- rather than merely to recommend they consult applicable state and local laws before playing -- is connected to Barney Frank’s proposed bill, the Internet Gambling Regulation, Consumer Protection, and Enforcement Act (H.R. 2267), which was passed by the House Financial Services Committee which Frank chairs and still awaits consideration by the full House.

If you recall, that bill, designed to create a mechanism by which to license and regulate online gambling in the U.S., had a number of amendments added to it by the House Financial Services committee, including a couple concerning “bad actors” or sites that would be denied licenses to operate in the U.S. going forward thanks to their having failed to comply with federal and/or state gambling laws prior to the new bill being passed. (Click here for a rundown on H.R. 2267 and all of those amendments.)

PokerStars has already said it doesn’t feel as though it should fall into that “bad actors” category, stating that in its view -- and that of the site’s legal counsel -- those amendments would not “adversely affect the availability of a license for a respected operator such as PokerStars” whose “activities in the US are and at all times have been lawful.”

Thus does blocking Washington state’s residents appear to some as fitting with the strategy to remain lawful and thus available to receive a license should H.R. 2267 ever become law.

Others wonder what this might mean moving forward.

Those folks are wondering about things like states “opting out” of the new law, should it pass. Or whether this decision might mean that if it were to happen down the road that PokerStars was not granted a license to operate in the U.S., it would not try to do so anyway. Or what other U.S.-facing sites (like Full Tilt Poker, especially) will be doing with regard to Washington. Among other concerns.

As with most things related to online poker/gambling and the law, I can’t claim to have any real idea where we’re headed. The news about Washington clearly isn’t good, though, whatever it may indicate.

Labels: , , , ,

Friday, July 30, 2010

Summer Reading

Summer ReadingNot a lot of time to write today, I’m afraid. I assume that’s okay, though. Lots of other summer reading available to you, if yr looking for such.

For example, there have been a ton of articles popping up all over concerning that House Financial Services Committee vote in favor of H.R. 2267, the Internet Gambling Regulation, Consumer Protection, and Enforcement Act. Seems like everyone has something to say about it. I added a couple more cents on the subject over on the Betfair poker site today, too: “Online Poker in the U.S.: On the House Financial Services Committee Vote.”

Incidentally, I have decided to create an archive page from which I’m linking all of my Betfair columns. Have had the chance to do a lot of fun things over there, including interviewing several folks and reviewing a number of poker books. I’ve made a little banner down the right-hand side which will get you to the page, or you can just click here to see it.

Was thinking of doing something similar with some my old PokerNews stuff, too -- that is, creating a page that links to the book reviews and all of those “Poker & Pop Culture” columns I wrote for them. In fact, I’m still working on all of my archive pages, including those for the various sections here on Hard-Boiled Poker (e.g., On the Street, The Rumble, etc.). Hope soon to have all that stuff in order and up to date.

'Lost Vegas' by Paul McGuire (2010)Speaking of book reviews and interviews, I’m continuing to read and enjoy Dr. Pauly’s chronicle of his time reporting on the WSOP (plus his other Las Vegas-based adventures). I am of course referring to his recently-published book Lost Vegas: The Redneck Riviera, Existentialist Conversations with Strippers, and the World Series of Poker. I’ll probably be penning a review of the book soon, and plan to try to interview the author about it, too.

Kind of an uncanny feeling, reading about all of these “characters” I’ve gotten to know over the last few years. Indeed, a lot of what I’ve been experiencing thus far has been a lot of filling in of gaps in my personal knowledge of my fellow bloggers and other media types, as well as in the recent history of the WSOP. A lot of “ahh... so this is where he/she came from” moments so far. Also a few “a-ha!” moments, too, with regard to certain mysteries and other behind-the-scenes stuff at the WSOP circa 2005-2008.

I haven’t quite finished the book, although I can already recommend the book to anyone interested in the poker media, Las Vegas, and particularly the post-boom growth of the WSOP over the last few years. Kind of feeling like PokerVixen was a few days ago when she tweeted “I’m this >< close to finishing @LostVegasBook. I’ve stopped though because I don’t want it to end.” Go visit Dr. Pauly’s Lost Vegas site for details about ordering.

And after you’ve done that, go have yourself a relaxing, air-conditioned weekend.

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, July 29, 2010

House Financial Services Committee Passes H.R. 2267

H.R. 2267, the Internet Gambling Regulation, Consumer Protection, and Enforcement Act, passes through the House Financial Services CommitteeAs you have surely heard by now, H.R. 2267, the Internet Gambling Regulation, Consumer Protection, and Enforcement Act, was voted on yesterday by the House Financial Services Committee and passed by a vote of 41 yea, 22 nay, and 1 present (i.e., an abstention). It is being described by some as a “bipartisan” vote, although only a few Democrats voted against it (four), and a handful of Republicans voted for it (seven).

The bill will now be considered by the entire House of Representatives. Before becoming law, it will have to receive a favorable vote from the House, then the Senate, then be signed by the President. There was some joking around on Twitter yesterday about how best to describe the situation with a poker analogy. Seems to me like what’s happened here is the equivalent of surviving Day 1 of the Main Event. Or maybe just surviving to the dinner break of Day 1. Such a long, long way to go.

As the high-frequency Twittering on H.R. 2267 indicated, there was a lot of buzz in the poker community regarding yesterday’s turn of events, with many -- including the Poker Players Alliance -- heralding the Committee vote as especially good for poker. “This is a great day not only for poker players, but for proponents of Internet freedom and individual liberty,” said former Senator and PPA Chairman Alphonse D’Amato.

Just to review, this was the bill first proposed by Rep. Barney Frank (D-NH) back in the spring of 2009, a version of an earlier bill Frank proposed during the previous Congress (the IGREA). Like Frank’s earlier bill, H.R. 2267 proposes a mechanism to license and regulate online gambling in the United States. If signed into law, it would put the Secretary of the Treasury in charge of issuing licenses to anyone wanting to run an online gambling site in the U.S.

The bill outlines a number of requirements of licensees, including having safeguards against fraud, money laundering, and “terrorist finance.” There’s other stuff in there about keeping kids from playing, watching out for compulsive or problem gamblers, and such. Licensees would also be required to collect taxes related to internet gambling.

Additionally, H.R. 2267 specifically shields the financial transaction providers from any liability when it comes to handling transactions for licensees. The bill also permits states and Indian tribal authorities to “opt out” and disallow online gambling in their jurisdictions, if they so desire.

Yesterday’s hearing including a “markup” of the bill during which Committee members proposed numerous amendments to H.R. 2267 and voted on them. Most of these amendments passed, while a few did not. Here is a quick summary of the 13 amendments that were agreed to by the committee:
  • 1. The so-called “bad actors” amendment (No. 2) adds that those who have committed gambling-related felonies be specifically prohibited from obtaining licenses, as well as those entities which have failed to use "due diligence to prevent any U.S. person from placing a bet on an internet site in violation of Federal or State gambling laws."

    In the online poker world, it appears this amendment could potentially have some consequence for those sites which have continued to accept U.S. bets post-UIGEA (e.g., PokerStars, Full Tilt, UB, etc.). Hard to say for sure, though. Of course, those sites would argue they have not violated any gambling laws -- including the poorly-worded UIGEA which fails to define "unlawful internet gambling." (Indeed, PokerStars already has said as much today.)

  • 2. An amendment (No. 3) specifically excluding licensees from offering sports betting -- except for “pari-mutuel racing as permitted by law” (i.e., horse racing).

  • 3. An amendment (No. 4) to prevent direct advertising of online gambling sites that targeted problem gamblers or minors.

  • 4. An multi-part amendment (No. 8) that appears to be redundant to many provisions already in the bill or part of existing Federal and state gambling laws, though does include the licensees making available some sort of “loss limit” option for bettors. This one also includes a specific note about players being at least 21 years of age, which would be a significant change from most sites’ current minimum age requirement of 18.

  • 5. An amendment (No. 9) modifying the “opt out” provision to give states and Indian tribal authorities more time to do so.

  • 6. Another amendment (No. 10) barring licensees from targeting minors in their advertising.

  • 7. An amendment (No. 11) that reiterates licensees would lose their license if it found they’re allowing minors to play on their sites. (Again, some of these amendments are essentially redundant either to the bill itself or to other amendments.)

  • 8. An amendment (No. 12) specifically stating licensees cannot accept credit card payments.

  • 9. An amendment (No. 13) disallowing those obtaining licenses to accept bets from customers who are behind on child support payments. (Thanks to PokerGrump for helping me read this one correctly.)

  • 10. An amendment (No. 14) clarifying that state lotteries aren’t part of the scope of that which is covered by H.R. 2267.

  • 11. An amendment (No. 15) that kind of builds further on the “bad actors” amendment by making very explicit the significance of sites having not prevented U.S. citizens from making online bets once the UIGEA was signed into law (on October 13, 2006). Again, this one seems mostly redundant to the earlier, first-agreed-to amendment, but does perhaps add a bit of extra attention to the distinction between sites that pulled out of the U.S. upon the UIGEA’s passage (e.g., PartyPoker) and those that did not.

  • 12. An amendment (No. 16) clarifying that licensees show that they are “majority-controlled” by U.S. persons.

  • 13. A “data collection” amendment (No. 17) requiring licensees to make public information about player behavior.
  • As I’ve said before here, I feel pretty much completely out of my element when trying to speculate about what could happen next when it comes to the legislative process. Kind of like getting involved in a game like Badugi where I am sort of familiar with the rules but to guess correctly about how things will proceed would probably require my getting lucky.

    My gut feeling is this bill will be met with a lot of resistance from the entire House, and perhaps even more from the Senate (if it were to get that far). I’m also a little less enthusiastic than some about the prospects for online poker in the U.S. under such a licensing scheme. Of course, if we start to see banks and financial transaction providers comply with the UIGEA in greater numbers, I think a lot of U.S. players would swiftly welcome the introduction of licensed and regulated online poker as a way to play.

    But like I say, I’m not even going to try to speculate further. All I know is I am an American who wants to continue to be able to play online poker. I also know I want to be continue to be able to write for sites who depend on online poker remaining healthy both in the U.S. and elsewhere.

    But I also know that despite my being an adult and responsible with my decisions, I live in a time and place where others are deciding about my being able to do such things.

    Labels: , , , ,

    Monday, July 26, 2010

    Hershiser’s Pitch for Poker

    Orel Hershiser at the 2010 NAPT Venetian eventAfter that summer spent at the Rio, where everything -- politics, sports, oil spills, etc. -- existed only in vague outlines for me while almost all of my attention was on the WSOP, it’s nice to be home where I can read a newspaper and take in a ball game now and then.

    Over the weekend I did both. I read The New York Times yesterday morning, then watched some of that exciting St. Louis-Chicago game on ESPN last night. One article I saw in the NYT yesterday was an interview with former major league great Orel Hershiser, who was, in fact, part of the announcing team for the Cards-Cubs game.

    And yeah, poker came up. Which is why I am mentioning it here.

    The article was quite short -- just eight questions -- in which the interviewer, Joe Brescia, mostly asks Hershiser about baseball, including questions about his announcing gig, his career, and for his thoughts concerning the current status of pitching today. The last question, though, is about poker.

    “You are an avid poker player,” Brescia begins. “You’ve beaten a few legends, including Ted Forrest, Allen Cunningham, and Freddy Deeb.” Brescia refers, of course, to that surprising run Hershiser had in the 2008 NBC National Heads-Up Poker Championship before finally losing to Andy Bloch in the Round of 16. Not quite as remarkable as pitching a major-league record 59 consecutive scoreless innings -- as Hershiser did to conclude that wondrous, Cy Young Award-winning 1988 season -- but a nifty feat, nonetheless.

    Brescia then asks Hershiser “How do you explain your success?” In fact, Hershiser has had more success in poker than we saw at that 2008 NBC event. He cashed in the 2010 NAPT PokerStars Caribbean Adventure event. He’s also done fairly well in some of the WCOOP events on PokerStars, including final tabling the 2008 $10,000 buy-in High-Roller NLHE event (finishing ninth).

    I remember seeing Hershiser at the NAPT Venetian event I helped cover in February of this year. (That is a picture of him from that event above, by the way, taken by Joe Giron.) If you look closely, you can see he has a signed baseball sitting in front of him. He eventually gave that as a souvenir to the person who knocked him out near the end of Day 2. That’s become a custom for Hershiser. I know he gave one to Annette Obrestad when she knocked him out of the first round the NBC National Heads-Up Poker Championship this past spring, and Obrestad -- not a big baseball fan -- wasn’t quite sure what it was about.

    Anyhow, I really like Hershiser’s response to the question. First of all, he doesn’t get carried away with the idea of his “success” in poker, which he obviously understands has been quite modest. Secondly, he immediately makes a distinction between poker and other gambling games that I like hearing made.

    “When I moved to Las Vegas,” Hershiser begins, “poker was something to do to stay away from gambling. That sounds funny, but I mean roulette and blackjack and all the places where the house has the edge. But in poker, it’s man against man and everyone has equal footing.”

    Hershiser here articulates an idea -- both succinctly and effectively, I think -- that should be familiar to anyone who has ever thought seriously about poker. Namely that while poker is gambling, or at least involves a chance element, it is also much, much different from other forms of gambling in which the skill component is severely muted or missing entirely.

    Hershiser goes on to suggest an analogy from baseball which is also fitting and helps illustrate how poker does indeed involve genuine skill and competition. “It’s like pitching,” says Hershiser. “It’s the same outline. What position am I in? Was this guy aggressive last time? Do I need to disguise my hand? I think I can bluff him. And at 51 years old, competing on my rear end when my body is shutting down is not bad.”

    That game-within-the-game between pitcher and batter can indeed be very similar to the heads-up battles that emerge at a table full of players. In both cases the match-up involves players employing various skill sets against one another but also engaging in an intellectual battle, too.

    I do appreciate Hershiser out there helping explain and represent poker in such a way. Meanwhile, on Capitol Hill this week that distinction between poker and other forms of gambling will be set aside as H.R. 2267, the Internet Gambling Regulation, Consumer Protection, and Enforcement Act goes into what is called the “markup” phase before it gets voted on by the House Financial Services Committee tomorrow.

    If the bill receives a favorable committee vote -- which Kevmath says “appears too close to call” -- H.R. 2267 will then move on to the entire House of Representatives for its consideration. The bill would still need to be passed by the House, then the Senate, then signed into law by the President. Meaning we’re still quite a long way away from any significant changes for online gambling in the U.S., I’d imagine.

    It’s an interesting moment for poker, I think. H.R. 2267 is designed to set up a licensing and regulatory scheme for the operation of online gambling sites in the United States. It makes no distinctions between poker and other forms of gambling, and so the further this bill moves along -- with the full support of the Poker Players Alliance, by the way -- the more poker’s supporters will be necessarily grouped with those supporting making other forms of gambling more available to Americans.

    Thus will arguments about poker being a “skill game” have to be set aside in the context of debates about this particular bill. Annie Duke did just that, actually, in her statement before the House Financial Services Committee last week, talking more specifically about individual liberty than about poker per se.

    From a practical point of view, I guess it doesn’t matter too much that poker gets folded in with other forms of gambling. Such will always be the case, and when it comes to legislators, attempts to distinguish poker as a “skill game” and therefore perhaps make it seem more acceptable to some from a moral standpoint are mostly going to be in vain, anyway.

    Still, as I say, I do appreciate the distinction Hershiser makes when describing why he likes poker. A pitch worth making, I think.

    Labels: , , ,


    Older Posts

    Copyright © 2006-2021 Hard-Boiled Poker.
    All Rights Reserved.